This article is based on tax law for the year ending 28 February 2025.

1. Background

A South African company purchased land, which is being subdivided into plots for the construction of houses. Once completed, each plot with its corresponding house will be sold individually. The company seeks to reflect the potential value of these properties on its balance sheet.


2. The Question

Can the company reflect the potential new value of the properties on the balance sheet, or would they be categorised as inventory, which cannot be revalued and presented at a higher cost? Additionally, can the company provide details in the inventory note of the Annual Financial Statements (AFS), specifying that the properties will be marketed and sold, for example, 20 units at R500k each, with a total value of R10 million?


2. Applicable Law 

ITA 58 of 1962, section 22(3)(a)(i)


3. Application of the Law to the Facts

It is agreed that the subdivided land is trading stock. For tax purposes, it will be recorded at the cost price of the land, apportioned to the individual plots, along with any further costs incurred to bring the stock to its condition and position as of the accounting date. This would include the cost of subdivision.

For accounting purposes, IFRS IAS 2 requires that inventory is measured at the lower of cost or net realisable value (NRV). NRV is the expected selling price of the asset, less any costs associated with selling it, such as fees or transport.

Frequently asked questions

How should subdivided residential plots held for sale be treated for tax?

As trading stock recorded at cost of the land apportioned to plots, plus further costs to bring the stock to its condition and location at the accounting date, including subdivision costs.

Can the company revalue the plots upward on the tax balance sheet because selling prices look higher?

Not for tax trading-stock purposes under the approach in the article; cost (as adjusted for bringing stock to condition and position) is the tax measure discussed.

What accounting measure does the article cite for inventory?

IFRS IAS 2: inventory at the lower of cost and net realisable value, where NRV is expected selling price less selling costs.

May an AFS inventory note mention intended marketing prices?

The question is raised in the facts; the legal discussion focuses on cost versus NRV measurement rather than approving a higher carrying amount for tax.