This article is based on tax law for the year ending 28 February 2025.
1. The Problem / Facts
A South African taxpayer who works abroad, makes contributions towards Give As You Earn (GAYE). SARS did not allow the GAYE contributions as a deduction. Is GAYE tax deductible in South Africa?
2. Applicable Law
ITA 58 of 1962, Section 18A
3. Application of the Law to the Facts
The Give As You Earn (GAYE) scheme, prevalent in the UK, allows employees to make charitable donations directly from their salaries before tax is deducted. Section 18A of the Income Tax Act, 1962 contains the criteria to be met for charitable donations to be considered tax-deductible in South Africa. Specifically, section 18A provides for deductions in respect of donations made to certain public benefit organizations (PBOs) within South Africa.
The key requirements are:
- The donation must be made to a PBO approved by the Commissioner.
- The taxpayer must receive a receipt from the PBO indicating that the donation qualifies under Section 18A.
- The deduction is generally limited to 10% of the taxpayer's taxable income (before the deduction of medical expenses).
Given that the GAYE scheme is based in the UK and the donations are likely going to UK-based charities, the contributions made through the GAYE scheme would not meet the criteria set out in Section 18A for tax deductibility in South Africa. This is likely why SARS has not allowed the GAYE portion as a deductible expense.
Frequently asked questions
Are UK Give As You Earn contributions deductible for a South African taxpayer?
Generally no under the article’s analysis, because section 18A deductions require donations to approved South African public benefit organisations with qualifying receipts.
What key section 18A requirements does the article list?
Donation to a Commissioner-approved PBO, a qualifying receipt from that PBO, and the usual taxable-income limitation on the deduction.
Why did SARS disallow the GAYE portion in the facts?
Because GAYE is a UK payroll-giving scheme and the donations are likely made to UK charities that do not meet section 18A’s South African PBO criteria.
Does working abroad change the section 18A analysis in this article?
Not on the facts discussed: deductibility still turns on whether the donation meets section 18A, which UK GAYE payments typically do not.
