CATEGORIES
- (44)Accounting & Financial Reporting
- (1)Accounting for Income Tax
- (1)Application of tax rates, s6(2) rebates
- (1)Assessed losses
- (10)Blogs
- (1)Business Advisory
- (8)Capital Gains Tax
- (1)Capital Gains Tax - Individuals Tax
- (1)Capital Gains Tax Implications of Trusts
- (2)Case study: Home office expense
- (1)Case study: Travel allowances
- (1)Company Formations
- (136)Corporate Tax
- (10)Customs and Excise
- (2)Deceased Estate
- (1)Deductions Pre-trade and prepaid expenses
- (1)Deregistration
- (2)Employer and Employee (PAYE and UIF Specific)
- (1)Estate Duty
- (1)Events / Webinars
- (11)Faculty News
- (2)Farming
- (166)Individuals Tax
- (1)Input - Customs Duty
- (3)Interest
- (18)International Tax
- (1)Nature of the rights of beneficiaries
- (1)Notional input tax
- (9)Payroll
- (2)Practical Payroll
- (2)Provisional tax (Link with other Taxes)
- (4)SARS Issues
- (1)Salaried Employees
- (156)Tax Administration
- (2)Tax Administration Part 2B: Resolving Problems with SARS using the Tax Ombud
- (1)Tax Administration Part 3B Dispute Resolution - Objection and appeal
- (3)Tax Dispute Resolution
- (1)Tax Opinions
- (3)Tax Update
- (1)Tax implications of loans to trusts
- (1)Tax residence
- (1)Tax returns and payments
- (3)Transfer-Pricing
- (1)Trust Income / Gain Allocations
- (1)Trust types and income allocations
- (10)Trusts
- (84)VAT
- (3)VAT periods
- (1)Wear and tear allowances
- (13)Wills, Estates & Succession
- (1)Zero Rated
- (2)eFiling
- Show All
[FAQ] The term “consultant” when assessing the S12E requirements
- 16 April 2021
- Corporate Tax
- The Tax Faculty
This article is based on tax law for the year ending 28 February 2021.
Background
- Company C has one director who is the sole shareholder. There are no other full-time staff except contractors.
- Company C has two sources of income streams – one does recruitment of candidates for the placement at different clients while the other is consulting services around strategy definition and implementation/delivery as well as software design/configuration.
- Company C would either place a contractor in a role at the client’s business (whom the client would manage to get the work done) or the director or one of the contractors would perform the work for the client directly on an output basis.
Assuming all other aspects of the S12E requirements are met, would the above "personal service" exclude them from qualifying for the S12E deductions and reduced tax rates?
Answer
The Income Tax Act
We suspect your enquiry relates to the existence of the word “consulting” in the definition of “personal service”. If so, you don’t need to worry.
In 2012, ITC 1860 74 SATC 371 provided us with a very helpful decision on the meaning of “consulting”, which SARS did not take on appeal. The taxpayer in question advised clients on how best to display their products on supermarket shelves so as to attract the most attention from customers. She called herself a consultant, so SARS disqualified her company from being an SBC.
The court held that the term “consultant” meant the giving of “professional” advice. This would be done by a person with a professional qualification or licence. A person advising on product display on supermarket shelves does not need a professional qualification in order to carry out that function. It followed that the taxpayer was not carrying out the function of consulting as contemplated.
In the present matter, we would suggest that “services around strategy definition and implementation/delivery as well as software design/configuration” do not need a professional qualification or licence. Therefore, it must follow that, even though the client describes itself as “consulting”, this does not mean consulting as contemplated in the definition of “personal service”.
Should SARS challenge this ITC 1860 should assist you with the case.
Webinar Commentary
Further webinar commentary on Current Issues Facing Corporate Taxpayers 2021 can be accessed here.