Cruel accrual? An important judgment for taxpayers in the property development industry

---

Cruel accrual? An important judgment for taxpayers in the property development industry

• 19 December 2019
• Individuals Tax
• Louis Botha and Heinrich Louw

Monday, 26 November 2018

Important:

This article is based on tax law for the tax year ending 28 February 2019.

Authors: Louis Botha and Heinrich Louw (Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr)

It is an established tax law principle that an amount will form part of a person’s gross income, in the year of assessment in which the amount accrues to that person. However, as illustrated by a recent judgment, where property-related transactions are concluded, the parties must consider whether s24(1) of the Income Tax Act, No 58 of 1962 (Act) applies to their agreement.

On 20 November 2018, the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) handed down judgment in the matter of Milnerton Estates Ltd v CSARS (1159/2017) [2018] ZASCA 155 (20 November 2018). The SCA had to consider whether Milnerton Estates Ltd (Taxpayer) had to include the purchase price of immovable properties sold in its 2013 or 2014 tax year of assessment. The Taxpayer was appealing against the Tax Court’s judgment, which court found that the purchase price of the properties accrued to the Taxpayer in its 2013 year of assessment, even though payment was only received in its 2014 year of assessment. We reported on this judgment in our Tax and Exchange Control Alert of 14 July 2017.

Facts

In 2013, the Taxpayer concluded 25 sale agreements of erven in the Parklands Residential Estate. The purchasers were required to pay a nominal deposit of R5,000 and the balance of the purchase price was payable against transfer. Although conditions regarding payment of the purchase price were not the same in all the sale agreements, in all 25 cases the purchase price was fully secured before the end of the 2013 tax year.

In terms of each agreement, the Taxpayer could only give possession of the property to the purchaser once it had obtained the approval of the local authority, to permit the passage of vehicular traffic on the completed roads in the development. In all 25 cases, the local authority’s approval was obtained before the end of the 2013 tax year, although in some cases possession was only given in the subsequent tax year. At the end of the 2013 tax year, the Taxpayer had not yet transferred the 25 stands to the purchasers. Therefore, it omitted the purchase price of each of the stands from its gross income for the 2013 year of assessment. However, SARS contended that in each instance, the purchase price had accrued to the Taxpayer in the 2013 tax year, or alternatively that it was deemed to have accrued to the Taxpayer in terms of s24(1) of the Act. It therefore issued an assessment in terms of which the Taxpayer was taxed on an amount of R6.8 million.

Click here to read more.

This article first appeared on cliffedekkerhofmeyr.com.

1 COMMENTS

LEAVE A COMMENT