Transfer Pricing Litigation, Trends and Lessons Learned
Duration: 2 hours
Price: R195.00
Transfer Pricing Litigation, Trends and Lessons Learned
Presenters : Carryn Alexander , Karen Miller
Overview
Transfer pricing disputes in South Africa have moved from the audit room to the courtroom, and the same intra-group price is now tested twice: for income tax, and again at the border. Courts and tribunals in Australia, the European Union, New Zealand and South Africa have ruled on how an arm’s length price is proved, and on whether royalties and price adjustments made after importation form part of the customs value of imported goods. South African customs law has followed: since 14 September 2026, new rules prescribe how importers must notify SARS of, and settle duty and VAT on, transfer pricing adjustments to related party imports.
This two-hour video examines leading South African and international decisions, the transactions attracting the closest scrutiny, and the practical lessons for multinational enterprises and their advisers in preparing, defending and resolving transfer pricing and customs valuation disputes.
Video Content
- Proving an arm’s length price: the Australian decisions in Roche Products Pty Ltd and SNF (Australia) Pty Ltd, and the lessons on method selection, comparables, sustained losses and the burden of proof
- Price adjustments after importation and the customs value in the European Union: Hamamatsu Photonics Deutschland GmbH, the Bundesfinanzhof decision that followed (VII R 2/19), the Dutch Rechtbank Noord-Holland and Tauritus (C-782/23)
- Royalties, licence fees and commissions in the customs value: Levi Strauss SA (Pty) Ltd in the Supreme Court of Appeal and Country Road Clothing (NZ) Ltd in the New Zealand High Court
- Transactions under heightened scrutiny: intra-group financing, intangibles and royalties, management and service fees, commodity and marketing hubs, and business restructurings
- Recharacterisation, and the weight courts give to legal form compared with economic substance
- Customs valuation: the new rules on transfer pricing adjustments to related party imports, and the duty and VAT exposure they create
- Evidence and procedure: contemporaneous documentation, expert witnesses, comparability analysis, the burden of proof and the limits on SARS changing the grounds of an assessment
- Dispute prevention: the SARS advance pricing agreement pilot, open to applications since 1 September 2026
Competencies Developed
On completion of this video, practitioners are able to:
- Explain the current litigation trends in transfer pricing and customs valuation, both in South Africa and internationally
- Identify the categories of transactions most exposed to challenge by revenue authorities and the courts
- Analyse the reasoning in leading cases and apply the principles to comparable client arrangements
- Assess how far a client’s transfer pricing documentation would withstand audit and litigation
- Evaluate how transfer pricing adjustments affect customs valuation, and the reverse
- Advise multinational enterprises on structuring, documentation and dispute strategies that reduce exposure to litigation
- Apply the lessons from decided cases to strengthen the defence of transfer pricing positions in audit, objection and appeal
Related Webinars
Transfer Pricing and Customs Valuation: Managing Risk and Alignment in Related Party Cross-Border Goods Transactions